Getting "Westernized" is generally what happens…

..when you move to the West:

Police in a Phoenix suburb say they have arrested an Iraqi immigrant suspected of running down his daughter because she was becoming “too Westernized.”

I am going to refrain from casting any judgment on Iraqi or Middle Eastern culture, as the facts aren’t here to make the assessment as to whether it was an attempted honor killing or anything of the sort. But no matter the facts of the case, it’s only natural to wonder why Faleh Almaleki thought becoming “too Westernized” was a bad thing. I can understand him wanting to retain his homeland’s culture, but if he thought Westernization was such a bad thing, well, it’s worth asking why he brought his family here as opposed to staying in Iraq. It’d also be interesting to see how many liberals would defend those who refuse to assimilate into American culture and say things like this — which look to me to be a clear consequence of tolerating those who are actively hostile to our culture and its norms — are an aberration rather than the norm. They would be right, of course, but what do you do when you’re dealing with more insidious effects of that, i.e. those of whatever nationality, for example, who refuse to learn to speak the English language? I am not against people coming to this country by any means, but if they’re going to come here it’d be best for all concerned if they were familiar with and friendly to its language and culture.

UPDATE: I accidentally deleted this post, but before I did, I caught Kelly in comments saying she could not understand Mr. Almaleki wanting to retain his culture. And on further reflection I agree with that. I suppose I might have come off as a cultural relativist in the original post and that wasn’t even the last thing I meant to do. No matter where you are, running down someone in your car just because she doesn’t conform to your homeland’s culture is just wrong, and on further reflection it also becomes quite clear that a culture that would condone that sort of thing really isn’t worth preserving.

Advertisements

Tags:

One Response to “Getting "Westernized" is generally what happens…”

  1. southtexaspistolero Says:

    Sabra (66.69.88.111)
    I would never think that you could come across as a cultural relativist. I think that in the best cases, immigrant cultures inform our own.

    This is obviously not the best case.
    October 30, 2009, 5:35:48 PM CDT – Like – Reply – Edit – Moderate

    Kelly (68.89.232.97)
    I’ve never read anything here that would make me say, “Oh yeah, that Pistolero guy… most liberal interpretation of ‘melting pot’ EVER!” If anything, I’d think you’re just guilty of being very polite. I’m sure you’ve been accused of worse.
    October 30, 2009, 6:20:45 PM CDT – Like – Reply – Edit – Moderate

    the pistolero (71.40.211.50)
    I would never think that you could come across as a cultural relativist.
    One could say I was just belaboring the obvious, as I am wont to do now and then. And I do try to be unfailingly polite, yes…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s


%d bloggers like this: